There is no doubt that in the world of fashion and beauty the ’90s are back. From chokers to crop tops and Poetic Justice box braids to Angela Chase-inspired bobs, it’s hard to miss the influence in contemporary culture. The dark nude lip (brown, gray and smoky purple) is one of the most wearable trends from the decade, and this time it has been reinvented in ultra-matte formulas that seem retro and modern at the same time—although finding the right shade can prove to be tough.

Thankfully, we now have beauty bloggers and social media to point us in the right direction, which is how I became introduced to ColourPop Cosmetics. At just $6 a pop, and with over 50 shades to choose from, it’s easy to see why people have jumped on the bandwagon. You can also purchase corresponding lip liners for an additional $5. Below, we test five of the top nude shades from the brand.

To say that these are long-lasting is an understatement. It took a lot of effort to remove the shades, which is great if you are looking for a color that will last all day through multiple cups of coffee. ColourPop also offers $5 off of your first purchase.