Skip to content
  • X

Subscribe

Magazine | Newsletters
  • Food & Drink
  • News
  • Culture
  • Style
  • Home
  • Family
  • Wellness
  • Things to Do
  • Travel
  • Best of NoVA
  • Best Restaurants
  • Top High Schools
  • In This Issue
  • Home
    • Food & Drink
  • 5 Spots for Old-Fashioned Ice Cream in Northern Virginia
diary godmother ice cream cone
  • Food & Drink

5 Spots for Old-Fashioned Ice Cream in Northern Virginia

Go on, get a double scoop.

By Maggie Roth June 24, 2025 at 6:00 am

We love specialty dessert shops as much as anyone else, but sometimes there’s nothing like a classic scoop of old-fashioned ice cream just like you got as a kid. Head to one of these five ice cream shops in NoVA to cool off with your favorite flavor.  

Peterson’s Ice Cream Depot 

This sweet shop in Clifton makes its treats inhouse, with 12 rotating flavors available every day. Stop in for a taste of strawberry, mint chocolate, chip, or cookies and cream, plus other seasonal kinds. Get a simple cup or cone, or mix it up with a sundae or milkshake — there’s no wrong answer. 7150 Main St., Clifton 

Pop’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream 

Step into the vintage interior of Pop’s and taste one of its classic flavors. It’s named for Ray “Pop” Giovanni, who started making desserts in the 1940s and served Eleanor Roosevelt ice cream. Grab a cone of peanut butter chocolate pretzel, Butterfinger coffee, or carrot cake. 109 King St., Alexandria 

The Dairy Godmother 

This staple Alexandria spot keeps it simple with a menu of frozen custard in vanilla, chocolate, and a rotating specialty flavor. Try flavors like Chocolate Rice Krisy (June 27 to 26), tiramisu (July 1 to 2), or a cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg flavor called Mozambique (July 15 to 16). 2310 Mt. Vernon Ave., Alexandria 

Toby’s Homemade Ice Cream 

With locations in Arlington and Vienna, Toby’s ice cream is made with all natural ingredients and flavors, with 16 percent butterfat content for a creamy result. Dig into a big bowl of salted caramel, vanilla chip, or pistachio to beat the heat. 5849A Washington Blvd., Arlington; 510 14th St. S., Ste. 70, Arlington; 280 Cedar Ln., Vienna 

Woody’s Ice Cream 

Tucked in Old Town Fairfax, Woody’s is a go-to for a sweet treat on the patio. It offers soft and hard ice creams in all the classic flavors, with the option to build your own sundae, float, or milkshake. 10435 North St., Fairfax. 

Don’t forget to vote in our 2025 Ice Cream Wars.

Feature image of Dairy Godmother by Rey Lopez

Maggie Roth

Maggie Roth

Contributing Editor

Maggie Roth is the former associate editor for Northern Virginia Magazine, where she covered news and culture in the NoVA area. Originally from New Jersey, she is a graduate of George Mason University and joined the magazine in 2021.

  • Email
  • LinkedIn

Trending in NoVA

19 Recent Northern Virginia Restaurant, Winery, and Brewery Closures

Virginia State Police Investigate I-66 Shooting in Fairfax County

3 Virginia Colleges Rank in ‘U.S. News & World Report’ 2027 Top 100 List

Northern Virginia Real Estate Agent Shot and Killed in Loudoun County

Discover Delicious Fall Treats at These 7 Northern Virginia Bakeries and Shops

things to do newsletter

Our Top Stories In Your Inbox

Our newsletters delivered weekly.

Subscribe

Feeds

RSS Feed Follow in Feedly

You May Also Like

three cocktails in halloween-inspired glasses

7 Halloween Pop-Up Bars and Bar Crawls Around Northern Virginia

apple cider and pumpkin cannoli at Bisonna Bakeshop

Discover Delicious Fall Treats at These 7 Northern Virginia Bakeries and Shops

Interior of Corso Italian

Italian Restaurant Permanently Closes in Arlington Following Flood Damage

  • X

Company

  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Writer’s Guidelines
  • Internships
  • Terms of Use

Magazine

  • Magazine
  • Subscription
  • Newsletter
  • Back Issues

Talk to Us

  • Contact Us
  • Submit an Event
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Shopping

  • Subscription
  • Back Issues
  • Plaques
  • Realtor Client Gift Subscriptions

On Newsstands Now

October 2026 things to do this fall cover

Copyright © 2026 Northern Virginia Magazine

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Hey AI.