9 Places to Order Delicious Thanksgiving Pies in Northern Virginia

Local bakeries are serving up seasonal sweetness — but you’ll need to order early to snag your favorite flavors.

By Dawn Klavon • Posted October 31, 2025 at 7:30 a.m.

Courtesy Founding Farmers

Pumpkin, pecan, apple, or chocolate cream — however you slice it, Thanksgiving pie cannot be missed. Skip the stress of baking and order ahead from one of these local favorites. Just be sure to mark your calendar — many shops sell out well before the big day.

Acme Pie Co.

Acme serves up handmade, hearty pies with a dash of attitude. Choose from a seasonal selection of delectable flavors: apple, mixed berry, pecan chocolate maple, proper chocolate chess, and more. Every pie boasts a perfectly flaky crust. 2406 Columbia Pike, Arlington

Alexandria Pastry Co

This family-run bakery blends Old World technique with modern flair. The pies are buttery, fragrant, and beautifully finished — the kind you’ll be proud to serve (and reluctant to share). 3690 King St., Alexandria

Amphora

The bakery is a Herndon institution, famous for its scratch-made pies and beautiful presentation. Try their pumpkin latte, apple crumb, or classic pecan — all baked fresh and delicious. 294 Sunset Park Dr., Herndon

Founding Farmers

Their pies are as renowned — farm-fresh ingredients and scratch recipes make these a sure bet. Flavors include classics like apple, pumpkin, and pecan. Multiple area locations

Livin’ The Pie Life

This cheerful Arlington bakery turns out some of the region’s most indulgent pies — from salted caramel apple to chocolate chess. Pre-orders for Thanksgiving pies begin on October 16. Consider ordering early and freezing your pie for Thanksgiving — it will still be delicious. 2166 N. Glebe Rd., Arlington

Mom’s Apple Pie

Mom’s Apple Pie uses local fruit and old-fashioned recipes that have earned cult status across the region. The signature apple pie is a must, but the chocolate pecan runs a close second. 220 Loudoun St. SE, Leesburg, 35246 Leesburg Pike, Round Hill

Pie Gourmet

This beloved Vienna staple is known for its rich, buttery crusts and classic fillings. Choose from holiday favorites like pecan or French apple, or savory flavors like chicken pot pie and veggie pot pie. 507 Maple Ave. W, Vienna

Randolph’s Pastries

Randolph’s is a neighborhood gem turning out European-inspired pastries and timeless holiday pies. Expect elegant desserts with perfectly balanced sweetness; it will be what everyone at the table is raving about. 4500 Cherry Hill Rd., Arlington

Feature image courtesy Founding Farmers

See More:

Thanksgiving

Dawn Klavon

Contributing Writer

Dawn Klavon is a seasoned writer and reporter with more than 20 years of experience in print and broadcast journalism. She contributes to a wide range of publications, including Northern Virginia Magazine, PEOPLE, Virginia Living, Bethesda Magazine, Arlington Magazine, and several military-focused outlets. Earlier in her career, she reported for multiple San Francisco Bay Area television stations, including KLXV, KKPX, and KFCB. She holds an MLA from Harvard University and a BS from Boston University.